What Would I Do to Fix The Economy?
March 14, 2008 by Miranda Marquit
Filed under Economy, Family finances, Trends
As many regular readers know, I’m not a big fan of recent “economic stimulus” efforts. They tend to be band-aids rather than solutions. And Jennifer Hofmann at My Organized Biz asked me what I would do.
So here it is:
There is no way for the government to fix the economy. And it can’t happen in a short period of time. These things are cyclical. Downcycles are inevitable. Trying to prevent them at all actually makes the economy more unstable, as we’ve seen since the last economic stimulus a few years ago (during G.W. Bush’s first four years). But if the government must meddle now (and government always does), it could focus on things that might help us “regular” folks. And do things that change the way the economy works right now.
Control of the economy should be returned to traditional middle class values of saving, working hard, and using credit sparingly, and not left as a debt-based economy designed to promote excessive consumerism and usurious earnings by creditors of all stripes.
And it’s all about prioritizing what’s in important in terms of spending.
I don’t think that bailing companies out constantly is overly helpful. At least, “saving” their stock values only teaches them that when they are stupid, the government will be there for them. That said, some help is needed in the financial sector. Mass bank failures would be devastating to everyone. But it should come with a price: Regulation.
Basic rules (not over-regulation) should be established to ensure that someone can pay for any home loan that they get. This means that borrowers should be approved at the re-set rate, and not at the teaser rate. Income verification should be more rigorous. I went through an income audit for my self-employment earnings so that I could get a decent home mortgage loan rate. Even though it was harder for me to get a home loan (I refused to pay the interest rate premium for a “stated income” mortgage), in the end I benefit for taking the trouble. This sort of thing should be explained to borrowers.
Better education should be taught about finances. Start teaching children in schools the value of money, and the expenses of credit and the problems associated with living beyond their means. This is something that could easily be added to the math curriculum.
Finally, the government should prioritize its spending. Part of our problem comes from the fact that too many hard working middle class families have problems making ends meet due to sky-rocketing health care costs and, now, transportation costs. Stop subsidizing oil companies and giving them tax breaks. Funnel money to research for alternative energy that would wean us off our fossil fuels (which also contribute to health problems and safety hazards). It would be less expensive as well. And universal health care would actually decrease the cost per person. This could easily be paid for if we stopped giving funding to the militaries of other countries. We wouldn’t even have to get out of Iraq (although that alone could pay for universal health care). Imagine if we weren’t responsible for portions of the military budgets of dozens of countries…
We live in America. We should be innovating ways to make things better, but cost less. Instead we’re maintaining the status quo. And paying for it with borrowed money.
Do you agree? Disagree? What would YOU do?


























Perhaps if the media stopped writing mainly doom and gloom stories aimed at panicking readers/viewers, there would be some upward swing to the economy. It seems every time a bad news story comes out, gas prices go up, stocks fall, people slow purchases, etc. We’re becoming controlled by the media (online and off). This won’t solve everything, but doom and gloom thinking never solved anything.
Yesterday’s news announced the first bank bailout by the Fed since the Depression.
http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601087&sid=abl8CI.8oF8U&refer=home
I agree that excessive gloom and doom is unnecessary (and perhaps prompted the event in the first place), but the basis of it is that the average person isn’t liquid anymore.
The average American has $9000 in credit card debt… and this inflated spending is propping up the economy. What kind of model is that?
The way I see it, as Miranda said, there needs to be an economic “reset.” This week, 70% of educated economists say we’re in a recession. I think this is a good and natural slowdown for what has been unrealistic, unsustainable growth at our personal expense.
Personally, I see values like frugality, conservative spending, and simplicity becoming more the norm for the average American. I can hope, anyway.
Thanks both of you for your remarks! I agree that the media has been a little too gleeful about all this. However, part of the problem is also to do with the fact that our consumerism is out of control. And also to do with the fact that if we’re not always in a state of growth, we think it’s bad. We need to realize it’s cyclical, and we need to be encouraged to be educated, and to prepare ourselves for naturally ocurring downcycles.
Today as the bailout did what to free market capitalism road to rich where did all those tv commericals go? Gas market is 2.21 gal retail marketup are at pump prices of 3.69 in South Carolina.We do not ask Why? The retail markup has been around 60 cents.The only fix today is police and trial by jury with imprisonment.This play by oil or gas whoever it is is greed.And their greed will make America fail.Mainstreet oil crisis should have been taken care of by Congress a long time ago in their own bailout.Free market issue Forget it and act or lose America’s mainstreet.